The Dynaco Tube Audio Forum

Dedicated to the restoration and preservation of all original Dynaco tube audio equipment - Customer support for Dynaco VTA tube amp kits, all Tubes4hifi.com products and all Dynakitparts.com products


    tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Share

    tubes4hifi
    Admin

    Posts : 1282
    Join date : 2008-11-30

    tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by tubes4hifi on Sun Mar 30, 2014 4:03 pm

    hey, that was fun, let's answer another question that comes up almost everyday.
    Do you want tone controls? I don't know, you tell me!
    Do I recommend tone controls? NO! Do I use tone controls? YES! Confusing? YES!

    OK, so if you think you want tone controls, the answer is yes, you probably do want tone controls.
    I perfectly understand that not everyone has perfect ears, perfect speakers, perfect room setup.
    I understand there is probably more poorly recorded music, than music that is recorded perfectly!!

    So what you need to know is that tone controls will always compromise sound quality.
    This is because using a circuit with tone controls means you need to have a minimum of 3X as much gain as you do without them.
    A high quality tone control circuit needs 20db of gain to overcome the losses of tone controls.
    Tone controls work two ways, by cutting gain (usually thru filters which just filter those tones to ground) or in worst cases
    by using negative feedback to reduce gain on those tones.
    To boost bass and treble (more likely than reducing it) those extreme frequencies need more gain, more amplification, which can lead to more noise,
    worse signal to noise ratio, more distortion, and usually all the other frequencies (the critical midrange) are subjected to negative feedback.

    These are the things we deal with in order to make the music sound better to our own ears, using our own speakers, our own rooms, our own recordings.
    We do need tone controls to overcome all these short comings, but we have to accept that the compromises involved are not as bad as the results.
    Are they better? They can be, or maybe not, that again, is a subjective question that only you can answer for yourself.

    Oh, so maybe you'd like my OPINION, rather than the facts as presented above?
    Sure! Do I like tone controls? NO! Do I recommend tone controls? NO! Do I use tone controls? YES! Sometimes, but I only use them when needed,
    as necessary, and when I am prepared to accept all those limitations to overcome my own personal set of limitations involving my own ears, my own speakers,
    my own listening room, my own recordings, some of which are awful, some have no bass, some have way too much bass, some are tinny, some are hollow.

    Hey, here's an idea for you. Need more bass? Get a subwoofer, you can dial in as much boost as you want or need. And guess what,
    then you don't need a bass control on your preamp!!! You don't need extra gain, extra noise, poorer circuit design. What a concept!!!
    So . . . . need more treble? Gee, let's think about that for a moment. Maybe I could add an extra tweeter, a more efficient tweeter, one with it's own gain control. . . .

    Hey, here's an idea for you. Make sure your listening room is at least somewhat enhanced to actually sound better.
    Do some research, read some books, buy some room treatments.
    Go all in !!! Buy a digital DSP EQ system for $10,000 and have it shape and perfect everything to your ears and your room! Really??? No, I think NOT!!!

    The bottom line - music is for enjoyment, and that is subjective, so do your own thing!!!
    And MY recommendations? Get the very best speakers you can afford, get your room setup correctly, buy better music, and THEN,
    either buy an SP14 (and a PH16 for phono) or buy an SP9 with tone controls, and then . . . . enjoy the music!! Simple!!

    peterh

    Posts : 679
    Join date : 2012-12-25
    Location : gothenburg, sweden

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by peterh on Sun Mar 30, 2014 4:24 pm

    Good post but ..
    it's seldom an issue of permanently adding bass or treble, it's an issue that some recording lacks ( or has too much) of something.
    It's not me room or my equiplment, it's my habit of enjoying records even if the recording engeneer smoked funny stuff or just had a bad day. Even then i would like the music to be "as good as possible".

    The discussion however might lead to something positive, a preamp might be like pas-4, with no built-in tonecontrols but with a loop for a tonecontrol that could be engaged at will.

    This would open up a market for "tonecontrol-units" that adds less "bad-sound" then eq-boxes.


    sKiZo

    Posts : 1308
    Join date : 2013-04-01
    Location : Michigan USA

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by sKiZo on Sun Mar 30, 2014 5:33 pm

    I use dynamic expansion. low bass synthesis, holographic imaging, hardware peq, speaker compensation, impulse correlation, rephasing,  software convolution, R128 loudness, etc ... but I don't use tone controls.

    Not sure if that's a yes or a no, but it's a definite maybe ... yeah ... definite!  jocolor

    corndog71

    Posts : 451
    Join date : 2013-03-19
    Location : It can get windy here

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by corndog71 on Sun Mar 30, 2014 9:52 pm

    No tone controls for me. Mine goes source-> preamp -> amp -> speakers. I got great speakers and room treatments. All I need. Well, that and great music.

    daveshel

    Posts : 147
    Join date : 2011-11-06
    Location : Tucson AZ USA

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by daveshel on Mon Mar 31, 2014 12:55 am

    I gave them up many years ago. My solid state preamp has defeatable tone controls and I haven't engaged them for years. My tube preamp doesn't have any. Except for the rare instance of playing a bad or old recording (which has yet to come up), I feel like I'd only need them if I didn't do my job correctly at some other point in the process - bad choice of gear, bad setup, bad acoustics.

    audiobill

    Posts : 270
    Join date : 2014-03-13
    Location : Philadelphia

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by audiobill on Mon Mar 31, 2014 5:26 am

    I try to avoid listening to any bad recordings, except for possibly early jazz guitar, which I play (badly!).

    So don't want the comprises that go with tone controls. OTOH, I do like a remote balance control for fine tuning imaging from my listening position.

    I'd like to see a remote option on the VTA preamps....the only thing they're lacking, IMO.

    deluxmon

    Posts : 17
    Join date : 2013-03-20
    Age : 62
    Location : DENVER

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by deluxmon on Mon Mar 31, 2014 9:49 pm

    tubes4hifi wrote:
    The bottom line - music is for enjoyment, and that is subjective, so do your own thing!!!
    And MY recommendations?   Get the very best speakers you can afford, get your room setup correctly, buy better music, and THEN,
    either buy an SP14 (and a PH16 for phono) or buy an SP9 with tone controls, and then . . . . enjoy the music!!   Simple!!

    That is it in a nutshell.....get the best speakers you can afford - ABSOLUTELY! buy better music - check out PONO....It will change how we hear music moving forward....ponomusic.com......

    Brap

    Posts : 83
    Join date : 2013-11-28
    Age : 61
    Location : Lisle, Illinois

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by Brap on Wed Apr 23, 2014 2:57 pm

    Just a "teensy" bit with my Parasound Halo for the Paradigm Studio 10V5's for the low end versus connecting a sub.............for now! ST-70 is the amp.

    MattR

    Posts : 3
    Join date : 2014-05-09

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by MattR on Thu May 22, 2014 11:22 pm

    I definitely want tone controls. I use them very sparingly, but I always like to have the option if I want it. I suppose my ear isn't as well defined as some "audiophiles" who look at tone controls as some kind of mortal sin. On my own pre-amp, I can't hear any difference with the tone switch defeated or activated (with the tone controls flat). Some say even having the defeatable switch puts an unnecessary step in the audio circuitry that will lesson the audio quality, but I don't care. I need the freedom to adjust the tone during those few occasions when I just need more bass or a bit brighter sound.

    audiobill

    Posts : 270
    Join date : 2014-03-13
    Location : Philadelphia

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by audiobill on Fri May 23, 2014 6:22 am

    Of course, equalizers introduce new issues, but may help with your challenge without redesigning components.....

    mark four

    Posts : 33
    Join date : 2011-08-12
    Age : 61
    Location : philadelphia , home of dynaco

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by mark four on Sun May 25, 2014 9:01 pm

    tone controls are removed from my pas3 . i  like the clean sound of no tone controls .

    MexicoMike

    Posts : 28
    Join date : 2014-11-21

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by MexicoMike on Sat Nov 22, 2014 9:41 am

    Many years ago I was of the "no tone control" camp. But I finally realized that a lot of records and CDs that I listened to sounded like cr@p. I belonged to that school of "listen to it as the producer/engineer INTENDED it." But I came to the conclusion that some of them apparently couldn't hear very well! Smile

    So now I use tone controls regularly. I have records/CDs that I need to cut the bass, some that I need to cut the treble, and some that the controls stay flat. But not having the ability to make an adjustment is just not workable for me any more.

    I once equalized my system for my seating position to obtain flat response to ensure (in my view) that I got EXACTLY whatever the recording engineer "intended." It was the worst sound I have ever heard and it would send me running from the room. Of course, that's a totally ridiculous concept because sound doesn't work that way. A violin from a foot away doesn't sound the same 30 feet away. Basically, a flat response at the listening position meant a hugely boosted high end.

    If it sounds bad then it's bad. IMO tone controls can make listening to many sources pleasant instead of Unpleasant.

    deepee99

    Posts : 1332
    Join date : 2012-05-23
    Location : Wallace, Idaho

    Tone control alternative

    Post by deepee99 on Wed Sep 09, 2015 9:26 am

    Bob Carver (at the time Audio Control) made a sweet little 5-band powered EQ back in the 1980s you could take completely off-line. Later versions of the Model 520 had a switchable and very unobtrusive rumble filter as well. Pots were rotary, not slide, and frequency adjustments were a very handy 35, 50, 120 Hz, and at 1kHz and 15.5 kHz. Had a tape/mon front-panel switch as well if that's how you wanted to set it up.
    Here's a pic of one: http://www.ebay.com/itm/Audio-Control-520-Active-EQ-Semi-Parametric-/252080978506?hash=item3ab1327a4a
    I used one for many years to perk up my Dahlquist DQ-20i speakers and still use one with my sand amp/Dynaco A-35 set-up.
    I have a spare and if somebody would like to "borrow" it for a month or two for the price of postage both directions - it's neither very heavy nor very large, you're welcome to it. Or you can find one now and then on AudioGon or Fleabay in the $50-$90 range. A cheap way to test the waters. PM if interested.

    Dave_in_Va

    Posts : 142
    Join date : 2013-04-02

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by Dave_in_Va on Sat Sep 12, 2015 7:23 pm

    Well, I took Dave's advice and actually bought the one one he referenced on eBay.
    Just hooked it up and it works fine (no scratchy pots!). It's the kind of thing I'd only use about 5% of the time. On some ancient mono singles mixes (Byrds, Beatles) I would occasionally need to kill a little of the bass because
    1. I drank a six pack and turned it up too loud.
    2. My room is actually too small to be cranking this thing on singles mixes.
    3. I didn't need to get into the world of room treatments.
    Minor problem solved for $67. Thanks Dave!
    And thanks to the forum for all of the great info. AND thanks for the great VTA gear!!


    Sponsored content

    Re: tone controls? yes - or no ?

    Post by Sponsored content Today at 9:40 am


      Current date/time is Sat Dec 03, 2016 9:40 am